Pierrefonds Library Expansion (Montreal, 2013): An Urban Connector
Since 2000, Phyllis Lambert has accepted twice to be juror of a competition for a library in Quebec, the first one in 2000 for the Grande Bibliothèque du Québec, and the second time in 2013 for the expansion of the Pierrefonds Library, at the periphery of Montreal. The GBQ was the beginning of a rich legacy of library competitions in Quebec, as Quebec has organized close to 15 library competitions since. The Quebec population is now in an ideal position to solicit a public debate about quality and innovation in this domain.
In the case of the Pierrefonds Library competition, which had a budget of under 20M$, it was not only about designing a library, but equally to integrate to an existing building, restructure the urban form, while valorizing the surrounding park. In some ways, it was analogous to the new Saint-Laurent Library competition of 2009 where competitors were required to "design an urban landmark". Both libraries situated at the periphery of the Montreal city center. Both had to valorize the surrounding green space. But the fundamental difference was that for Pierrefonds, a historical library from the 1980's had to be repurposed, bringing with this its share of constraints and opportunities. Consequently, the firm Chevalier Morales Architectes participated in both competitions, winning the Pierrefonds Library competition.
As in most competitions today, sustainability was an important criterion however the stakes were not only focused on the general characteristics of the building construction, but rather on the local - the local richness of the site as a place of abundant resources, a project that can stimulate local citizen engagement and activity, and the local cultural development that such a place could engender in terms of creativity and knowledge. In other words, competitors were asked to think of the library as an ecosystem.
How did the finalists innovate along all these possibly conflicting requirements, with projects that had to dialogue in this heterogeneous context? The four finalists included:
(1) Atelier Big City + FSA Architecture + L'O.E.U.F.;
(2) BGLA + Coarchitecture;
(3) Dan Hanganu + Groupe A.; and
(4) Chevalier Morales Architectes + DMA architects.
Atelier Big City + FSA Architecture + L'O.E.U.F. chose to resolve the majority of the library on one floor and included a rhythmic series of skylights and courtyards. This frank and bold decision provided an effective connection to the surrounding garden, however, in the eyes of the jury, of which Jacques Plante was president, it presented the schema with a series of challenges in terms of access and control of entrances: crucial questions of security for a library. The fact that complementary services were located in the only vertical element in the form of a tower was not convincing in the end.
The BGLA + Coarchitecture proposal gathered a series of classic tectonic devices, almost literally interpreted. The intricate brickwork, which constitutes the majority of the project's materiality, covers the entire form. Surprisingly included is a large hearth in the main space (Semperian ?), perhaps pushing the metaphor of a 'home away from home' too far.
The modernist flavour of the project by Dan Hanganu + Groupe A. focused on an entirely different element. Hanganu, in a lyrical voice, did not hide from a certain admiration for the existing building designed in the 1980's by one of his former mentors A. Vescei member of team Rosen Caruso Vescei + Gagnier Gagnon. The oral presentation dedicated a large part to the virtues of the existing, leaving far too little room to explain the new project: a tension between the old and the new somehow failed in conveying a clear project.
This confusion was unlike the extreme pedagogical clarity of the presentation for the project offered by the winning team of Chevalier Morales Architectes + DMA architects during the public presentations. Even if at first glance, we may have thought that the irregularity of the star-shaped composition could have been seen too complex in that it could not be explained in a simple elevation or perspective. This was not the case since, when the architects explained their project during the public presentations, they started by contextualizing the larger urban space considering Pierrefonds in the greater Montreal picture, zooming progressively, from the local structure, to the park and its components, as well as to the accesses, carefully focusing on the architectonic details and aesthetics of their proposal. The jury unanimously recognized the degree of innovation on many levels - the bold yet convincing form in a hybrid context of the park and the existing building, the integrative approach to design, and their typically nuanced attention to context which models the project from the outside in order to liberate the interior spaces. The culminating point of their approach: an aesthetic of the whiteness focusing on the slightest variations of light.
Can we say that a library judged as excellent starts with a clear perception of its relationship with its larger context, the fluidity of spaces, its clarity of vision, of discourse, and of presentation? The visitor shall judge....
The Pierrefonds-Roxboro borough launched a design competition in 2013 for the expansion and redevelopment of Pierrefonds Public Library in a bid to improve existing library services as well as offer new services to the rapidly expanding local population.
This is a new type of library, focused on various essential activities and encouraging the actions and contact between users, documents and media. The library becomes an ecosystem, a means to live and work together. The citizen takes on an active learning role in this context, following a "do it yourself" philosophy that enables him to take an active part in his own development as well as his community's by doing things.
The library's renewal as an informational and cultural hub within the community will make it a vector for sustainable local development. The library is part of a greater plan to stimulate citizen activity, becoming the heart and soul of the neighbourhood.
The new library must:
- Give the public access to services, information, resources and spaces, encouraging community empowerment.
- Facilitate citizen participation in the development of culture and knowledge
- Encourage literacy in children as well as continuing development for teens and adults
- Inspire the public and stimulate creativity
- Improve citizens' quality of life
(From competition program)
(Unofficial automated translation)
Following the sharing of comments, the members of the jury unanimously designated the Chevalier Morales Architects + DMA architects consortium as the winner of the competition for the following reasons:
- The integration approach and the conceptual approach demonstrate thorough and sustained research;
- This project stands out for its understanding of the vision statement and its architectural transposition:
- The architectural response to the search for the 21st century library is clearly expressed and affirmed;
- Remarkable flexibility of spaces;
- Effective functionality of spaces;
- The only project that brought the leadership team (DCSLDS) and library staff together in one area.
Following the competition, the designer and the user will finally be able to sit down at the same table and make certain adjustments in order to optimize the achievement of the targeted objectives. All finalists have expressed a desire to develop their project in close collaboration with the sponsor. The jury underlines the following recommendations for the further development of the winning project:
- The project should be subjected to a value analysis.
- The maintenance aspect of the building should be examined in depth.
- An analysis of the corners of the building is suggested to optimize the use of sunlight, especially for the main entrance on the north side
- The Pierrefonds Boulevard entrance would benefit from being more significantly marked by bringing the public functions closer to the multi-purpose room.
- The cross staircase represents a strong element that must not be altered in the development of the project.
(From jury report)
(Unofficial automated translation)
Michel Beaudry, Architecte
Guylaine Beaudry, Directrice
Sophie Charlebois, Architecte
Dominique Jacob, Directeur
Phyllis Lambert, Architecte
Jacques Plante, Architecte
Oscar Ramirez, Architecte
Marie D. Martel
Stage 1: Call for entries
June 10, 2013 to July 8, 2013
Stage 2: Finalists' proposals
July 10, 2013: Signature of mandates to Finalists
July 10, 2013: Site visit / Developer+Finalists meeting
July 10, 2013: Finalists' services begin
July 10, 2013: Start of question period
August 28, 2013: End of question period
August 30, 2013: Final answers to questions
September 11, 2013: Submission of entries
September 18, 2013: Technical Committee
September 24, 2013: Interviews with Finalists and presentation of Submissions
September 25, 2013: Jury deliberations and selection of Winner
October 1, 2013: Winner announced
October 3, 2013: Publication of results
(From competition brief)
(Unofficial automated translation)
Chevalier Morales architectes and DMA architectes Consortium win Pierrefonds Public Library competition, Canadian Architect, 2013
Four finalists chosen for Pierrefonds Library competition, Canadian Architect, 2013
Cheryl Cornacchia, Montreal firms awarded $400,000 in competition to design Pierrefonds library, West Island Gazette, 2013, Montréal
Finalists announced for Pierrefonds Public Library renovation project, 2013, United Kingdom
Marco Rinaldi, Chevalier Morales Architectes wins Pierrefonds Library Competition, 2013
Résultats du concours d'architecture pour la bibliothèque Pierrefonds, à Montréal, 2013, Paris
Concours d'architecture de la bibliothèque Pierrefonds : les gagnants annoncés, 2013
Concours d'architecture pour la bibliothèque de Pierrefonds, 2013
CONCOURS – Arrondissement Pierrefonds-Roxboro – « Rénovation et agrandissement de la bibliothèque de Pierrefonds », 2013
La bibliothèque de Pierrefonds lance un concours d'architecture pour son projet de rénovation et d'agrandissement, 2013, Montreal
France Tardif, Lauréat du concours d’architecture – Bibliothèque de Pierrefonds, 2013
Arrondissement Pierrefonds-Roxboro, Avis d'appel de candidatures, 2013, Direction des stratégies et transactions immobilières, Montréal
Lancement du concours d’architecture dans le cadre du projet de rénovation et d’agrandissement de la bibliothèque de Pierrefonds, 2013, Ville de Montréal Arrondissement Pierrefonds-Roxboro, Montréal
Concours d’architecture pour le réaménagement et l’agrandissement de la bibliothèque de Pierrefonds Quatre finalistes sont choisis !, 2013, Ville de Montréal Arrondissement Pierrefonds-Roxboro, Montréal
Consortium Chevalier Morales architectes et DMA architectes lauréat du concours d’architecture
pour la rénovation et l’agrandissement de la bibliothèque Pierrefonds, 2013, Ville de Montréal Arrondissement Pierrefonds-Roxboro, Montréal
- Appel de candidatures
- Rapport du jury (global)
- Rapport du jury (global)
- Revue bibliographique
- Texte du concours